Erin Lichy Calls Brynn Whitfield’s ‘Sisters’ Statement Outrageous: ‘Quite the Reach’

Erin Lichy Calls Brynn Whitfield’s ‘Sisters’ Statement Outrageous: ‘Quite the Reach’

Erin Lichy is setting the record straight following Brynn Whitfield’s recent comments. After the Real Housewives of New York finale aired, Brynn gave an interview where she described her relationship with Erin Lichy as sisterly — but Erin’s response was clear: that’s a bit of a stretch.

Erin Lichy Calls Brynn Whitfield’s ‘Sisters’ Statement Outrageous: ‘Quite the Reach’

In her Rolling Stone interview, Brynn shared her feelings on the cast following the reunion, saying, “Erin [Lichy] feels like a sister. I was just texting with her and [her husband] Abe the other day, I feel like I’m fine with them.” But Erin Lichy was quick to challenge this assertion, taking to Instagram to make her stance clear.

“To say we are sisters is quite the reach…” Erin wrote in a comment. “We haven’t spoken or seen each other in months other than Brynn thanking Abe for clearing up the intention for the call.”

Erin Lichy Calls Brynn Whitfield’s ‘Sisters’ Statement Outrageous: ‘Quite the Reach’

Erin didn’t hold back when discussing her disappointment. Reflecting on the friendship she hoped to see with Brynn, Erin explained, “I really wanted Brynn to win so bad. I was excited to watch her shine like I am with all my girlfriends. Each woman on this show is special and smart, and I really was excited for us collectively. But Brynn always had all this childhood trauma that I was particularly excited to see her break free from. Yet, here we are…”

The expecting mother didn’t stop there. Erin also took aim at Brynn Whitfield’s decision to stand firm in her narrative rather than owning up to her actions. “An article doubling down instead of saying, ‘Hey, I messed up,’” Erin said. “It’s upsetting to read for all of you viewers, can you imagine how it feels for us? This show is supposed to be FUN, it’s all I tried to do throughout, yet somehow things kept getting twisted and turned…”

Erin acknowledged her own naivety in the situation but emphasized the importance of honesty. “I very much was naive and fell victim to much manipulation,” she admitted. “I swore I wouldn’t comment, but this article is so triggering to me and I just can’t stay silent.”

Finally, Erin made her boundaries clear, writing, “I am not saying I’m perfect, but I’m fair and I stand up for what’s right when it counts. So respectfully, f—k off.”

Do you think Erin fell victim of manipulation?

Related posts

Rebecca Minkoff Exits RHONY After One Season to Focus on Family and Career

Brynn Whitfield Confronted for Twisting the Truth and Manipulating the Cast on Explosive RHONY Reunion

‘Real Housewives of New York City’ Producers Start Casting Call Before Season 15 Reunion Even Airs

5 comments

PjC January 23, 2025 - 3:05 pm
Erin is right to distance herself from a false "sister" label. Brynn lied, as she has soooo often with sooo many many conversations. This is real HWs and NOT real family.
Richard January 23, 2025 - 10:32 am
If you look at readings across-the-board for the shows, they've dropped, and something needs to be done. And it's because the craziness the false narrative and all the BS surrounding the show. You can't call this reality TV when they're filming and someone makes a mistake or doesn't come across like you want them to and have them do a retake or several. That's not reality TV that's bullshit. get back to the basics Bravo the reason we started watching these shows was because they were enjoyable and the cast did not feel as if they are celebrities they all meshed together that was good reality TV not the scripted shit.
Richard January 23, 2025 - 10:25 am
They are all manipulators, Erin especially none of these women are perfect. None of them have been loyal to each other but what do you expect? They're not friends in real life. They were thrown together on this show. That's a joke..
Champagne Hangover January 23, 2025 - 9:27 am
RyNy83 January 23, 2025 - 8:39 am
This did not require a response from Erin. Get a life.
Add Comment

This website uses cookies to improve your experience. We'll assume you're ok with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. Read More