Roxanne 
Teddi Mellencamp is opening up about her heartbreaking split from boyfriend PJ Conley, revealing that he told her he couldn’t see a future with her despite their relationship bringing her happiness during one of the most difficult periods of her life.
The former Real Housewives of Beverly Hills star, 45, became emotional while discussing the breakup with Dolores Catania during the October 30 episode of Two Ts in a Pod, admitting that she was still struggling to process the conversation.
Teddi, who has been navigating her recovery from stage IV melanoma that spread to her brain and lungs, revealed that PJ, 31, ended their relationship after what initially seemed like a wonderful evening together.
She admitted that she hadn’t been able to discuss the situation with anyone before opening up on the podcast.
“I went out with the Valley Guy last night, and we had a really good time at dinner, and after dinner, he’s like, ‘Should we talk, you know, about the future?’” Teddi recalled.
According to Teddi, PJ wanted to have a serious conversation about where their relationship was headed.
But while Teddi has been focused on living day to day amid her ongoing health challenges, PJ apparently had a clearer picture of what he wanted his future to look like.
“He’s just like, ‘I have to tell you, let’s talk about the future. I know where my life is going,’” Teddi explained.
She then revealed that PJ brought up how well things had gone when she met his family, particularly considering their 14-year age difference.
“He goes, ‘I was so shocked when you met my family and how well it went. Because I thought they were going to be a little bit more not accepting about the age difference and stuff.’”
But what came next caught Teddi off guard.
“And he goes, ‘But when I look at a future, I don’t see you in it.’”
According to Teddi, PJ admitted that he felt terrible about not being able to give her what she wanted from their relationship.
The confession was especially painful because Teddi believed the relationship had brought joy and excitement back into her life following an incredibly difficult year.
“Whether he knew it or not, he was breathing life into me,” Teddi admitted.
“But now I feel like, am I just not good enough?”
The emotional admission comes just months after Teddi and PJ made their relationship Instagram official in August 2026.
Teddi first introduced PJ to her followers after attending her father John Mellencamp’s concert at the Hollywood Bowl.
“First he met a cougar. Then he met The Cougs,” she joked in the caption, referencing their age difference and her father’s performance.
The couple reportedly met on the dating app Hinge and quickly developed a connection.
During a previous interview with Extra, Teddi revealed that PJ had helped her look forward to activities outside her usual routine.
“He’s really fun,” Teddi shared at the time.
She explained that her health struggles often left her exhausted by late afternoon, making evening plans particularly challenging.
“It’s like one of those things where I am able to look forward to something to do after 4 p.m., which is very difficult for me,” she explained.
Teddi joked that PJ would encourage her to go out for dinner at 7 p.m., even though she was usually ready to wind down much earlier.
She also recalled how nervous she was about their first date after meeting on Hinge.
According to Teddi, PJ suggested meeting at Casa Vega at 7:30 p.m., but she was so uncomfortable with the late dinner time that she asked her friend Amy to accompany her beforehand.
The two women ended up having dinner together before PJ even arrived.
“So when he arrived I’m sitting there with another girl,” Teddi recalled, laughing about the unconventional first date.
Despite their age difference, the relationship appeared to be progressing well.
Teddi previously revealed that PJ had met several members of her family, including her siblings and father, and had gotten along with them.
He had also met her children and her estranged husband, Edwin Arroyave.
During an August episode of Two Ts in a Pod, Teddi shared that PJ had fit into her family surprisingly easily.
She also joked that Edwin had teased PJ about their age difference.
At the time, Teddi described the relationship as peaceful and fun, explaining that PJ made her laugh.
However, Teddi’s latest admission suggests that while the couple enjoyed spending time together, they ultimately had different expectations about their future.
The breakup comes amid Teddi’s ongoing recovery from serious health challenges.
In February 2025, Teddi underwent emergency brain surgery after doctors discovered multiple tumors.
She later revealed that her melanoma had spread to her brain and lungs, requiring additional treatment.
Although she has shared encouraging updates about her cancer status, Teddi continues to deal with the physical and emotional effects of her diagnosis and treatment.
During a recent appearance on The Jenny McCarthy Wahlberg Show, Teddi revealed that she has struggled with speaking, writing and completing everyday tasks following brain surgery.
She also admitted that she experiences difficult emotional days and has been working through feelings of depression, anger and trauma.
The former Housewife explained that she once considered herself a perfectionist but has since been forced to adjust her expectations and accept that some days simply getting out of bed is an accomplishment.
Against that backdrop, her relationship with PJ appeared to give her something positive to look forward to.
In fact, just days before revealing their split, Teddi had spoken positively about their relationship while explaining why her divorce from Edwin had not yet been finalized.
During that interview, she described things with PJ as a “slow burn,” acknowledging that he was still adjusting to her public life and complicated personal circumstances.
Now, Teddi is left processing the end of a relationship she believed had helped her find happiness again.
