Andy Cohen is clearing up why some major Summer House topics did not make the final reunion edit.
While fans watched three episodes of the Season 10 reunion, there were still several conversations that apparently hit the cutting-room floor, including mentions of former cast member Paige DeSorbo and the alleged video involving Amanda Batula and West Wilson.
During an episode of SiriusXM’s Andy Cohen Live, a caller asked Andy whether Paige was brought up during the reunion.
“Did you ask anything about Paige specifically?” the caller asked.
Andy replied, “Yeah, we talked about Paige a bunch.”
That reveal is interesting because Paige was not prominently featured in the reunion episodes that aired, despite her deep ties to the current cast. Paige announced her exit from Summer House in 2025, nearly one year before Amanda and West confirmed their romance.
Before leaving the show, Paige, Amanda and Ciara Miller were one of the show’s closest friendship trios. That made Amanda and West’s relationship even messier for fans, especially since West previously dated Ciara and Amanda was one of Ciara’s closest friends.
Amanda announced her separation from Kyle Cooke in January after four years of marriage. Just two months later, she and West released a joint statement confirming that their friendship had evolved into something romantic.
Another topic that did not air in the final reunion episodes was the alleged video of Amanda and West, which made headlines before they publicly clarified their relationship status. The clip allegedly played a role in Amanda and West deciding to release their March statement.
Andy said that was also discussed during the reunion.
“It was brought up several times,” Andy said. “We had two supersized episodes and one normal episode, and still — we shot from about 10:30 in the morning until nine at night. So this stuff was all brought up.”
Andy admitted he was surprised the third reunion episode was not also supersized.
“I was surprised part three wasn’t supersized. If I had been producing it, I would’ve added [it] supersized,” he continued. “You’re bringing up stuff that is interesting and that I would’ve wanted to hear about too. Yes, we talked about it.”
The admission will likely frustrate some fans, especially because viewers have been invested in the full timeline of Amanda and West’s relationship. Throughout the reunion, Amanda and West were grilled over when things turned romantic, how much they hid from the group and why Ciara and Kyle were left feeling blindsided.
Ciara made it clear she felt betrayed by both her ex and her former best friend, while Kyle had to process his estranged wife moving on with someone inside their friend group.
Paige’s name being discussed off camera is also notable because fans have wondered what she knew, how she felt about the fallout and where she stands with Amanda and Ciara now.