Erika Jayne and Teddi Mellencamp SLAM RHOC’s Lie Detector Company

The Real Housewives universe never runs short of drama, but this time, it’s not just the cast members under scrutiny. Erika Jayne and Teddi Mellencamp are calling out the lie detector company featured in recent episodes of The Real Housewives of Orange County, and they’re not holding back.

Erika Jayne and Teddi Mellencamp SLAM RHOC’s Lie Detector Company 3

On their podcast, Two T’s in a Pod, the Real Housewives of Beverly Hills alums shared their doubts about the validity of the polygraph results used during a chaotic confrontation involving Gretchen Rossi, Katie Ginella, and others.

In the episode, tensions boiled over after Emily Simpson brought in a lie detector company to get to the bottom of the conflict. But Erika and Teddi were quick to question how the results played out, particularly the fact that Gretchen passed, while Katie failed several key responses.

Erika noted that Gretchen passed the question of whether she told Katie and Jennifer Pedranti that she was drugged, despite flashbacks appearing to show otherwise.

“How is that possible?” Teddi exclaimed. “This is where I am struggling.”

Erika agreed and questioned the credibility of the results, calling out the inconsistency. The two reviewed several of Katie’s failed answers and were baffled that Gretchen passed so easily in comparison.

Erika Jayne and Teddi Mellencamp SLAM RHOC’s Lie Detector Company 4

Their skepticism didn’t end there. Erika was quick to recognize the lie detector guy from another Bravo show.

“I didn’t like that the lie detector test was the same guy who did the Vanderpump lie detector test,” she said.

Teddi echoed her concern, questioning the integrity of using the same team again.

“I was like, if it’s the same company over and over, like what are we doing? Is this the only guy we can get?”

They also speculated that the results may have been steered in a certain direction. Referring to a moment when Gina told Gretchen “There’s a plan,” Teddi suggested that the lie detector team might have been given a heads-up or instructions.

“It makes it seem like the lie detector people were given specific instructions,” Teddi said.

Erika agreed, adding simply, “Oh, I’m sure.”

With Erika and Teddi now voicing their concerns publicly, fans are left wondering whether the polygraph drama is just another made-for-TV moment or if something more orchestrated is at play behind the scenes.

This Real Housewives scandal might not be about who’s telling the truth, but who’s controlling the narrative.


Related posts

Gretchen Rossi Says She Was Protecting Tamra Judge

Teddi Mellencamp Admits She Is Struggling Amid Stage 4 Cancer

Tamra Judge Opens Up About Latest Breast Augmentation — Despite Previously Swearing Off Implants

17 comments

ontoiran September 5, 2025 - 12:03 pm
The Bravo resident lie detector test administrator???, such blatant BS.
Steve September 4, 2025 - 3:32 pm
Well this fan is not left wondering if this was just another made-for-TV moment. Of course it was!
ontoiran September 5, 2025 - 12:09 pm
I’m feeling pretty silly about the waste of precious time on this ridiculous, dumber than a D rated 50’s Sci-Fi movie! At least these hags lip movement match the sound.
AnEnigmaWrappedInSnark September 4, 2025 - 2:46 pm
The whole thing was so absurd, all the way down to the lady polygrapher inserting out loud, her personal (bitchy) opinion that Katie was "full of shit" ?. However, does this all make for good reality TV, hell yeah.
ontoiran September 5, 2025 - 12:13 pm
I’m currently studying the confessional of Emily wearing black sport bra with the half up hair do??? Me thinks she’s looking veddy masculine, enter the cross dressing HW IDK, it’d be tv gold!!!
AnEnigmaWrappedInSnark September 6, 2025 - 5:00 pm
Guuuurl ... WTF is up with that lady wrestler look? #Chyna realness https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/0f81514f6a70a96069a55d9cf64bb73802bf817a3eda30b7e26cf04af666f21b.png
ontoiran September 8, 2025 - 2:56 pm
Yep, that’s the one! Emily lay off the testosterone, today!
AnEnigmaWrappedInSnark September 8, 2025 - 4:29 pm
I am still catching up, and just saw the scene where Stinkface takes Gretchen to the doctor to have a testosterone pellet shot into her @, so now I see why Emily is looking so manly.
ontoiran September 8, 2025 - 2:56 pm
Yep, that’s the one! Emily lay off the testosterone, today!
ontoiran September 5, 2025 - 12:13 pm
I’m currently studying the confessional of Emily wearing black sport bra with the half up hair do??? Me thinks she’s looking veddy masculine, enter the cross dressing HW IDK, it’d be tv gold!!!
NikkiJax September 4, 2025 - 11:44 am
This fan here isn't wondering, I completely agree that it is a manufactured made for TV moment.
E.A. Fisher September 4, 2025 - 10:04 am
Whoever in production thought this was a good idea should be fired ASAP!!!
Jules September 4, 2025 - 9:01 am
Let's not forget Katie was sick and throwing up before they announced about the lie detector tests. The women giving the test even noticed Katie was sick. The realty is the only person guilty on "naked wasted" night is Tamra!
Champagne Hangover September 4, 2025 - 9:48 am
Just yet ANOTHER example of how pseudoscience (along with the ‘trust the science’ crowd ?) have INTENTIONALLY defiled and corrupted truth which is with God, no matter how many tin can contraptions these glorified witch doctors come up with. And those who wish to bicker facts can instead ponder on just why polygraph tests are inadmissible in a court of law. Okaaaaay? ? https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/5070dcadbb6a92f2cb74a673a9c38d66b6968e75268c55d649dff700c81c1572.gif
Champagne Hangover September 4, 2025 - 9:48 am
Just yet ANOTHER example of how pseudoscience (along with the ‘trust the science’ crowd ?) have INTENTIONALLY defiled and corrupted truth which is with God, no matter how many tin can contraptions these glorified witch doctors come up with. And those who wish to bicker facts can instead ponder on just why polygraph tests are inadmissible in a court of law. Okaaaaay? ? https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/5070dcadbb6a92f2cb74a673a9c38d66b6968e75268c55d649dff700c81c1572.gif
AnEnigmaWrappedInSnark September 4, 2025 - 3:16 pm
They ain't even that "scientific". Polygraph machines work by measuring involuntary physiological responses that are believed to be indicators of stress and anxiety, just like the $25 BP machine sitting on my desk that I got from Walgreens, and EKG app on our Fitbits.
AnEnigmaWrappedInSnark September 4, 2025 - 3:16 pm
They ain't even that "scientific". Polygraph machines work by measuring involuntary physiological responses that are believed to be indicators of stress and anxiety, just like the $25 BP machine sitting on my desk that I got from Walgreens, and EKG app on our Fitbits.
Add Comment