Andy Cohen Says He’s “Drawing the Line” With Jen Shah’s Return to RHOSLC Ahead of Her Prison Release

Former Real Housewives of Salt Lake City star Jen Shah is just days away from walking out of prison, but according to Andy Cohen, fans shouldn’t expect her to walk back onto Bravo anytime soon.

Andy Cohen Says He’s “Drawing the Line” With Jen Shah's Return to RHOSLC Ahead of Her Prison Release 3

Shah, who pleaded guilty to conspiracy to commit wire fraud for a nationwide telemarketing scheme that targeted elderly victims, was originally sentenced to 6.5 years behind bars in 2023. After multiple reductions, she’s set to be released on December 10.

Despite the seriousness of her crimes, Shah’s arrest and imprisonment only fueled more public fascination, leaving fans wondering if Bravo would ever welcome her back. Cohen, however, has repeatedly shut that door — and did so again this week.

During Tuesday’s episode of Radio Andy on SiriusXM, he made it crystal clear: “She’s not coming back to the Real Housewives of Salt Lake City.” He also noted he couldn’t see Bravo putting her on another series either.

Still, that doesn’t mean Shah won’t find her way back onto screens. Cohen admitted he fully expects her to continue her reality TV career elsewhere. “I wish her all the best in her next life,” he said. “I would assume she’ll wind up on a reality show of some kind, but it won’t be anything that I’m working on.”


Shah’s arrest remains one of the most memorable moments in Housewives history. Cameras were rolling during Season 2 as she got a mysterious phone call while boarding a bus for a cast trip. She claimed her husband was in the hospital and abruptly left. Minutes later, federal agents showed up asking where she was, telling the women they “just needed to make sure she was okay.”

The cast quickly realized something wasn’t adding up and speculated the call she received was actually a tip about her impending arrest. Footage later showed law enforcement officials at Shah’s Utah home as the investigation unfolded.

Throughout the season, Shah insisted she was innocent and maintained that the accusations were false. Several of her castmates even traveled to New York City to support her at what was supposed to be the start of her trial — only for Shah to plead guilty at the last minute.

Related posts

Britani Bateman’s Ex Arrested After Alleged Stalking, Doxxing Her While She Was in NYC

Meredith Marks Defends Herself Amid Ongoing RHOSLC Airplane Drama

RHOSLC’s Mary Cosby Accused of Financial Extortion by Former Church Members in Explosive New Doc

10 comments

AnEnigmaWrappedInSnark December 3, 2025 - 2:39 pm
Fluke off Andy; if it were up to you. you would already be offering her a snowflake, but you're owned by NBC/Universal (who's owned by Comcast) and have no say in the matter. Of course that's not to say they have any scruples either ... Shahshank simply ain't worth the heat they would take.
Zap It December 3, 2025 - 3:16 pm
Makes sense...purely a "business" decision.
Zap It December 3, 2025 - 3:16 pm
Makes sense...purely a "business" decision.
Lisa's lost ring December 3, 2025 - 8:52 am
Now Andy and Bravo have a moral compass? Where was that moral compass when the NJ convicted felon stole 13 million dollars?
Champagne Hangover December 3, 2025 - 9:29 am
Pfft… Andy and his virtue signaling- AS IF!!! ?? Andy is only dabbing butt hurt ointment on his chapped ass cuz Jenn told him to pound sand re: the pre-prison interview he was salivating over (cuz OF COURSE the lil’ demon was ?). CLEARLY Jenn’s Bravo redemption arc was contingent upon that interview, and Jenn gave Bravo the big EFF YOU by backing out (probably for good reason, idk ????). I’m NOT a Jenn fan AT ALL, never was, BUT I’ll concede she makes great reality (train wreck) tv. I’d have a minuscule speck of respect for Andy (shhh ? no I wouldn’t) if he would just admit the REAL reason he won’t Stan for Jenn, but because of his egregious hypocrisy, I hope Jenn busts out the Islamophobia card just to bunch Andy’s panties and make him squirm. Mazel THAT, ahole!!! ??? https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/9f7e3b5759e45183545266cddf2b99fd398fa63543db7b4fe46df4aa4c3af1c4.gif
Champagne Hangover December 3, 2025 - 9:29 am
Pfft… Andy and his virtue signaling- AS IF!!! ?? Andy is only dabbing butt hurt ointment on his chapped ass cuz Jenn told him to pound sand re: the pre-prison interview he was salivating over (cuz OF COURSE the lil’ demon was ?). CLEARLY Jenn’s Bravo redemption arc was contingent upon that interview, and Jenn gave Bravo the big EFF YOU by backing out (probably for good reason, idk ????). I’m NOT a Jenn fan AT ALL, never was, BUT I’ll concede she makes great reality (train wreck) tv. I’d have a minuscule speck of respect for Andy (shhh ? no I wouldn’t) if he would just admit the REAL reason he won’t Stan for Jenn, but because of his egregious hypocrisy, I hope Jenn busts out the Islamophobia card just to bunch Andy’s panties and make him squirm. Mazel THAT, ahole!!! ??? https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/9f7e3b5759e45183545266cddf2b99fd398fa63543db7b4fe46df4aa4c3af1c4.gif
AnEnigmaWrappedInSnark December 3, 2025 - 3:30 pm
Andy was indeed butt hurt and could barely even contain his contempt for JS. He gets that way when one of his bitches steps out of line. https://uploads.disquscdn.com/images/22da9154be476012ffc2f538fc32eeb3d8a0bcb8bda850e2f169e943a25792a4.png
D.D. December 3, 2025 - 8:42 am
You heard him, everyone? Andy possesses STRONG values and morality! Except when it concerns, let say, someone like Erika, because it is acceptable to steal from orphans and widows, to level false accusations, and to ruin the existence of a designer who lost everything, even the child he was in the process of adopting. We must not exaggerate!
D.D. December 3, 2025 - 8:42 am
You heard him, everyone? Andy possesses STRONG values and morality! Except when it concerns, let say, someone like Erika, because it is acceptable to steal from orphans and widows, to level false accusations, and to ruin the existence of a designer who lost everything, even the child he was in the process of adopting. We must not exaggerate!
Add Comment